It was a gift, keep it.

My Love, do you realize just how much
your words hurt and confused me?
It is NOT just a dream,
we are meant to be together.
We are both willing to sacrifice so much
for the other because our love is true.
I willingly give up my immortal life
and you are willing to give me up.
But, I can't give up you,
I can't leave with you here.
It would eat away at my soul
until I was like the walking dead.
I know you are trying to protect me and
I know Atar might have had a part in that.
Maybe an idea he gave you
that I would be better off in Valinor,
but, I could never be better off without you.

- Silivren Ithildin